2009 Annual Halloween Pumpkin Contest

Hi folks!  The 2009 Pumpkin Contest has a new sponsor this year seeking out the best burgers in the World!

But Today we are seeking out the best Pumpkins in the world.

Previous Pumpkin competitions can be found at

2007 Pumpkin Contest 2008 Pumpkin Contest

The rules are simple, below you will find the pumpkin carvings from various members of our family (posted anonymously). All we ask is that you leave a comment voting for your favorite.

-Update –

A winner has been found! In the end the spooky carvings of #3 pulled ahead of #2 for the victory.

There have been a few requests to see this scary champion in daylight! Well, brace yourselves! Here it IS!!!!!!!!

pumpkin winnerScary face

Thanks for all who voted this year and we look forward to next year!

#1 – 1 Vote

Ugly face

#2 – 11 Votes


#3 – Winner 14 Votes!!!

Scary face

#4 – 3 Votes


#5 – 1 Vote


#6 – 2 Votes


32 Responses  
  • Dennis Sukholutsky writes:
    October 29th, 20099:50 amat


  • Garrett writes:
    October 29th, 20099:52 amat

    I cast my vote for number 2, with #1 right behind…

  • Shayla writes:
    October 29th, 20099:54 amat

    #2 – It’s like a crazy pirate pumpkin, very cool!

  • Vijan writes:
    October 29th, 200910:01 amat

    I’m with Garrett…I vote for #2 with #1 close behind. I like #4 and #6’s attention to detail but they just don’t do it for me.

    #2 may also be at an unfair advantage due to the photo coincidentally being taken with much better lighting than the rest (you can actually see the pumpkin and not just what was carved)

  • Judy R. writes:
    October 29th, 20092:05 pmat

    #2 but I also like #1–it looks there’s a similar voting trend here!

  • Shak-daddy writes:
    October 29th, 20092:24 pmat

    #3 is classic…it screams “I am Jack’s smirking revenge”

  • Corey writes:
    October 29th, 20092:52 pmat

    i vote for # 3!! he is scary

  • Terry B writes:
    October 29th, 20093:25 pmat

    I vote for #3.

  • Rebecca writes:
    October 29th, 20093:31 pmat

    #4 – that is some skilled carving.

  • Joemoney writes:
    October 29th, 20096:30 pmat

    Number 5 received a vote from Kitty. She left her vote with the picture instead of this page. Thanks Kitty!

  • Adam writes:
    October 29th, 20096:36 pmat

    #3 is very scary indeed. Reminds me of Nightmare Before Christmas.

  • Barry Richardson writes:
    October 29th, 20096:49 pmat

    #2, No comment, what can you really say about a pumpkin?

  • Kathy Richardson writes:
    October 29th, 20097:03 pmat

    #2, Evidently, that’s how I look lately(my teenage daughter said I was psycho!

  • Barry Richardson writes:
    October 29th, 20097:05 pmat

    #3 Obviously!!!

  • talane writes:
    October 29th, 20098:26 pmat

    hmmm. last year I got myself in trouble voting for one…but I guess I’ll take a chance. I think I’m going to have to go with 2, then 3, then 5. hope we’re not in a fight! xoxox

  • Jen writes:
    October 30th, 200910:56 amat


  • Sylvia writes:
    October 30th, 200911:04 amat

    My vote is for #3 – very scary with #2 a close second

  • Joemoney writes:
    October 30th, 200911:05 amat

    Christina Voted for #4. She left her vote with the picture instead of this page.

    She wrote “It’s just funny!”

  • Joemoney writes:
    October 30th, 200911:11 amat

    Josh Stibrich voted for #3. He left her vote with the picture instead of this page.

    He Wrote “I like the sinisterness of this one. Looks like something out a B level scary movie.”

  • Ray writes:
    October 30th, 200911:17 amat


  • Brandon writes:
    October 30th, 200911:18 amat


  • Julia Figueroa writes:
    October 30th, 200912:38 pmat

    Hmmm . . . this was tough, but I have to go with #2 as my first choice, #3 as a very, very close second. Good job, everyone!

  • Alan writes:
    October 30th, 20091:02 pmat

    My vote is for #3

  • Justin writes:
    October 30th, 20091:48 pmat

    My vote is for #2, with #3 a close second …

  • Channi writes:
    October 30th, 20094:31 pmat

    I vote for #2 (I hope this is April’s) P.S. Brandon votes for #2 also 😉

  • Dave writes:
    October 30th, 20095:53 pmat

    I vote for Amie’s, and I hope it’s #3, ’cause that’s my favorite.

  • Kathy Erwin writes:
    October 30th, 20096:46 pmat

    # 1 for sure

  • Jacque writes:
    October 30th, 20097:14 pmat

    I vote for #2 I just love how simple it is and cute

  • superkittensleftoutbecauseotherswerescared writes:
    October 30th, 20098:36 pmat

    i want to vote for none of them. Conspiracy!!!!!! But just to make it interesting, Super Kitten votes for the cat #6!

  • Joemoney writes:
    October 30th, 200911:27 pmat

    Lorena Voted for #3. She sent an email to Sara instead of leaving the message.

  • Stacy writes:
    October 31st, 20097:48 amat

    They’re all great! But I’ll vote for #4.

  • Riverton writes:
    October 31st, 20095:46 pmat

    Number 3 since there were no Louisiana pumpkins entered (allowed) this year.

© Copyright Burger Tyme 2023